We used the finalists as our everyday tumblers, taking them along with us on errands, on walks, and to the gym to see how they fared out in the world. Whichever stainless steel tumbler you choose, you will likely find you carry it with you often. When they were first released, the only option was stainless steel.
On the flip-top lid, you can press the mouthpiece cover securely into the sipping port to create a leakproof seal. And though the straw lid is only leak-resistant (given the very nature of straws), it has a rubber gasket that seals snugly around the straw. This double-walled stainless steel tumbler kept beverages just as cold as two of our other picks, the Yeti Rambler and Stanley’s The IceFlow (but not as cold as the RTIC Everyday Tumbler). The Simple Modern vessel also kept hot drinks warmer for longer than our other picks. This tumbler has a sloped lip, which makes sipping easy, and the smooth, lid-locking mechanism is easy to operate while you’re driving. However, this vessel leaks more when it’s knocked over, and it doesn’t keep drinks as cold as our other picks.
They’re also leakproof making them easy to take with you throughout your day. Ozark Trail offers a tumbler similar to Yeti for a discounted price. It should be noted, Ozark Trail sells a pink tumbler as well. This pink Yeti tumbler is to honor those battling and recovering from breast cancer.
Tumblers, insulated water bottles, and travel mugs are, of course, very similar—they all keep drinks cold or hot for long periods of time. Most insulated water bottles are leakproof (thanks ozark trail chair to their screw-top lids, which require two hands to open), and they don’t have sipping ports. Travel mugs, typically intended for warm drinks, have sipping ports that seal securely to prevent leaks. Tumblers, geared more toward cold drinks, may also have lids with built-in ports, but they don’t seal as securely as the ones on travel mugs. Tumblers often have a wider mouth, to accommodate ice cubes, and they may include a straw for sipping.
My own personal beverage drama every summer has really pushed me to do this review. To me, worrying about the temperature of the drinks I have on my boat is the absolute last thing I want to be thinking about when I am heading out on the water. Cooler’s have become somewhat of a status symbol in the outdoors and many equate the bigger brands with better quality. A higher price tag should mean a higher quality product, right?
After extensively reviewing the data from the travel logger, we found that—drumroll, please—the two tumblers performed exactly the same. I’ll pause for shock value, but there’s no real difference between the two other than ozark trail tumbler the price tag and that the Yeti is dishwasher safe. Putting them side by side, the Yeti and Ozark Trails tumblers look exactly alike.
The Orca records a 123.2deg reading and the Ozark Trail has hit 124.8deg. The Yeti has now drained 16 ounces of water and the remaining ice is turning to ozark trail canopy slush. The Orca has drained 15 ounces and the Ozark Trail 14 ounces. This double-walled stainless steel tumbler didn’t keep beverages cold for as long as the RTIC Everyday Tumbler, but the difference wasn’t huge. Over nine hours, the Everyday Tumbler kept water 2 degrees colder than the Yeti Rambler. No straw lid can be completely leakproof, but this quarter-turn lid comes close.
At the six hour mark, the pavement temperature soared to 142.4deg. The external temperature of the Yeti rose to 122.9deg, the Orca rose to 110.3deg and the Ozark Trail climbed to 117.3deg. The Yeti has now drained 8 ounces of water, the Orca drained 7 ounces and the Ozark Trail drained 8 ounces. The tumblers were checked every two hours and water was drained from each tumbler into a measuring cup.