Watching ice melt was probably the most difficult task of the tests I performed—only because it seemed to take forever for the ice to melt in each tumbler. I started the test first thing when I got to the office and was waiting for hours on end. By the time I left the office about eight hours later, the ice still wasn’t entirely melted and the water levels in both tumblers seemed to be at the same level. The ice in the Orca Chaser melted at the 11 hour 35 minute mark for second place in the test. But the ice melted fast as the side of the smaller tumbler took a lot of heat. Wirecutter is the product recommendation service from The New York Times.
We used the finalists as our everyday tumblers, taking them along with us on errands, on walks, and to the gym to see how they fared out in the world. Whichever stainless steel tumbler you choose, you will likely find you carry it with you often. When they were first released, the only option was stainless steel.
I tested the same three tumblers on one of the hottest Alabama summer days in early August. The temperature was in the mid-90s with a heat advisory in effect. The 20-ounce CamelBak Horizon tumbler excels at keeping contents cold.
If you are adding warm drinks to your ice, you will see reductions in the overall length of time your ice will stay cold. So there you have it, when looking at just the ability to keep ice cold over a period of 6 days the Pelican has just slightly won, but we are talking about decimal points. I have to say that I am very impressed with the performance of the Ozark Trail 45Q cooler. This cooler is not only smaller in its overall size but also a fraction of the price of the competition.
The Orca records a 123.2deg reading and the Ozark Trail has hit 124.8deg. The Yeti has now drained 16 ounces of water and the remaining ice is turning to slush. The Orca has drained 15 ounces and the Ozark Trail 14 ounces. This double-walled stainless steel tumbler didn’t keep beverages cold for as long as the RTIC Everyday Tumbler, but the difference wasn’t huge. Over nine hours, the Everyday Tumbler kept water 2 degrees colder than the Yeti Rambler. No straw lid can be completely leakproof, but this quarter-turn lid comes close.
The Stanley collection at Target has the classics everyone loves plus Stanleys in new styles and popping bright colors for the summer. It includes not only the famous tumblers but also lunch boxes, cocktail shakers, pitchers, and more. Stock up for this summer or keep in mind for birthdays and events — this collection can make an unforgettable gift. After ozark trail tumbler enduring the highest external temperature recorded during the test, the ice remaining in the Yeti Rambler has melted.
And the flip-top and straw lids both have removable rubber gaskets, which you can pop out to do a deeper cleaning. A tumbler can also replace disposable cups at fast-food restaurants or gas stations. Of all the tumblers we tested, the 24-ounce Simple Modern Classic Tumbler impressed us the most. This stainless steel, double-walled vessel was among the most leak-resistant tumblers we tried. It also kept our drinks as cold as—and, in some instances, colder than—tumblers bearing more-recognizable brand names. I also took into consideration how cold or hot to the touch each tumbler was when filled with liquid and tipped each one over to see if they would leak.
The Ozark Trail tumbler won our second ice retention challenge, this time but a wider margin. It held ice in brutal Alabama August heat for 12 hours and 42 minutes. One reason the Ozark Trail tumbler held ice so much longer may be due to the fact that the sun was so low in the sky. For the last hour, the tumbler was not being blasted by direct sunlight anymore. After seeing the previous test story, several folks asked me how these tumblers stack up on a really hot day outdoors.