That said, a griddle can’t necessarily replace a traditional gas grill. They don’t work as well in the higher temp ranges… You won’t get those classic grill marks… And you won’t be able to cook over an open flame. As flat top grilled food will always be in direct contact with the cooking surface, cooking at temps higher than this may scorch the outer crust… Before the inside has a chance to cook through.
All of the products below have been tested and are highly recommended. In general, for an investment like this, it’s sometimes easier to consider your eventual cost per use. If this is something you will use weekly, it may be worth a larger upfront investment. If you envision using the grill less frequently, you may not need to spend as much. We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. These top picks offer a faster, more convenient way to get the benefits of wood fire cooking.
If you’re a fan of White Castle’s sliders, a griddle grill is the way to go. I can’t say for sure, but I think the cool spot on the left side of the griddle is due to the design of the left burner on the 3 burner model. One of the most attractive features of the Pit Boss Ultimate Griddle is the “proprietary, non-stick armored ceramic cooking surface”. But don’t let that innovative feature lead you to believe that your food will never stick to the surface. Even in the best non-stick skillet, your scrambled eggs may stick and you may have some residue leftover on the bottom of the pan.
Some will set you back a few hundred dollars, others cost thousands. One word of caution – don’t confuse a cheap cooker with a cooker that is good value. Some find the slide and sear system many Camp Chef and Pit Boss grills use incredibly useful, while others would rather have a dedicated grill for searing and use their pellet grill for low and slow. That is not to say that all features are simply gimmicks and should be dismissed as such.
The ceramic coated surface comes ready to cook on right out of the box. All in all, it’s a great griddle to own and I’ve been very happy with my experience with the Pit Boss griddle these last several months. This was a big pro for our family, because we like to tailgate pit boss electric smoker and we have outdoor get-togethers quite often. In fact, I recently took my Pit Boss on a 3 hour road trip to a family reunion in a state park. It fit perfectly in the trunk of my wife’s SUV, and I was able to cook up 6 packs of bratwursts for the whole family to enjoy.
I know there are a TON of different websites that review griddles and flat top grills. I also know that most of those writers have absolutely zero experience with using the actual product that they’re “reviewing”. It’s one thing to just list some specs and features and give a surface-level comparison of a few products. But it’s completely different to have actual real-world, hands on knowledge of how a griddle operates and what you personally like and don’t like about it.
If you have a stainless steel flat top… That’s the extent of it! These temps are still hot enough to sear… But not quite hot enough to risk burning. Two sturdy folding shelves are provided on the sides of the grill, with a shelf and a half below for storage. A grill this big can pit boss pellets be hard to move, so it sits on large, four-inch locking caster wheels. That was a complete comparison of Blackstone vs. Pit Boss griddle so that you can decide which one is best for you. The one that is best for you will depend on your budget, cooking needs, and other factors.
So, can you still make foods that require an on-the-griddle “chopping” method like cheese steaks or Chopped Cheese sandwiches? Just like with any griddle that you buy, there are both pros and cons. I know that I’ve said in the past to not let the “extras” sway your decision when choosing a flat top grill, but the paper towel holder is actually a nice feature to have. The entire griddle cooking surface can be removed from the wheeled stand so that you can easily take your Pit Boss griddle on the go, either camping or tailgating. Just unhook the propane tank from the unit, unlock the hinges on both sides, and the griddle top is ready to go.